Geotags: 

FaroeBritainGreenlandIcelandNorwayRussiaEuropean Union

Mackerel, herring, and blue whiting: overfishing is structural

In the Northeast Atlantic, everyone decides for themselves and the time has come to find an agreement on fishing quotas.

Atlantic countries must find an agreement on fishing quotas
The Marine Stewardship Council is urging NEAFC member countries to reach an agreement on fishing quotas and end a years-long dispute. (Photo: NOAA FishWatch/PD)

The UK, Norway, Iceland, the Faroe Islands, the EU, Greenland and Russia must find an agreement on catch limits for mackerel, herring and blue whitingThis is strongly requested by the Marine Stewardship Council, which has urged the coastal countries of theNortheast Atlantic to put an end to a dispute that has dragged on for years, and which risks destroying key fish stocks.

For some years now, in fact, the members of the Northeast Atlantic Fisheries Commission (NEAFC) unilaterally set their own fishing quotas, which consistently exceed the limits indicated by scientists from the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES). Over the last ten years, over 7,2 million tons of mackerel, Atlantic-Scandinavian herring and blue whiting in excess of what is suggested by the best available scientific knowledge.

Annual fishing quotas: the agreement that never comes

Last November, at the conclusion of the last annual meeting of the Northeast Atlantic Fisheries Commission (NEAFC), the disappointment was strong. Most of the members of the NEAFC (which are the United Kingdom, Norway, Iceland, the Faroe Islands, the EU, Greenland and Russia) opposed the EU proposal to set, for mackerel (Scomber Discombrus), a total allowable catch in line with the scientific advice provided by the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES). The mackerel, reminds the European Commission, is the most important fish stock in the North-East Atlantic, and is already below the minimum sustainability level recommended by ICES. Last year's meeting also ended without an agreement on the allocation modalities for blue whiting (Micromesistius poutassou), which is also overexploited.

“The 44th annual meeting of NEAFC will be remembered for the resistance of most of its members to adopt decisions on fisheries management and the protection of vulnerable marine ecosystems in line with the best available scientific knowledge,”

he then declared the Deep Sea Conservation Coalition.

The next NEAFC annual meeting, the 45th, is scheduled for November. Expectations are high: the EU will continue its fight to bring catch limits into line with scientific advice, while other members will pursue their intention to defend one's shares, which in the absence of an agreement between the parties will be re-established unilaterally by the various States.

The Mackerel Wars and Overfishing in the Atlantic
The Mackerel Wars have been going on since 2010. In 2014, it was believed that the issue had been put to rest, but with Brexit, the fragmentation of the interests at stake has become structural. (Photo: Ed Bierman / CC BY 2.0)

How did we get here? The Mackerel Wars

They started in 2010, theIceland le Fær Øer, which established the first unilateral quotas for mackerel – which, due to rising Atlantic water temperatures, had begun to appear in huge quantities in their Exclusive Economic Zones. In 2010, Iceland's catch increased from 2.000 tonnes in the mid-2000s to 130.000 tonnes. Those of the Faroe Islands increased from 25.000 to 150.000 tonnes. Thus, the annual mackerel catch from the north-eastern Atlantic stood at over 770 thousand tons, against the 570 thousand indicated by ICES as a safe limit. The so-called “Mackerel Wars”.

Great Britain, Norway, and Ireland opposed the unilateral decisions of Iceland and the Faroe Islands, going so far as to deny access to their ports to fishing vessels from those states. In 2012-13, the Faroe Islands approved unilateral captures (tripled compared to the past) also for herring and blue whiting.

In 2014, it seemed that the dispute had been concluded. Following a trilateral agreement between the EU, Norway and the Faroe Islands, the parties involved divided their mackerel quotas, assigning approximately 72% to the EU and Norway and approximately 12,6% to the Faroe Islands, reserving the remaining 15,6% as a "reserve" for Iceland and Russia. But according to the MSC, the sanctioning pressure was withdrawn without a global agreement and the stocks did not find stable protection, maintaining the global shares higher than ICES advice.

Then came BrexitThe United Kingdom joined the NEAFC as an independent coastal state, demanding the redistribution of its share of the stock. The following year, Norway had already increased its mackerel quota by 55%, again unilaterally. The "Mackerel Wars" have never really ended. So, since then, everyone sets their own limits. That consistently exceed the maximum sustainable catch limit (Total Allowable Catch) recommended by ICES scientists.

Towards the London Summit: the MSC's appeal

Il next NEAFC annual meeting, which will be held in London between 10 and 13 November, will be a decisive test for the resolution of a dispute that has been going on for years, and which puts at risk some of the most important fish stocks: mackerel, but also herring and blue whiting, on which no binding multilateral agreements have yet been reached.

Failure to reach an agreement could lead, as has happened in the past, to the loss of the MSC sustainability certification of many Atlantic fish catches. The Marine Stewardship Council It was pretty clear. In a long statement, the Council urges the coastal states of the North-East Atlantic to agree on sustainable fishing quotas, and to “finally put an end to the multi-year dispute over the allocation of fishing volumes for mackerel, Atlanto-Scandinavian herring and blue whiting".

"States must agree on binding quotas to ensure the long-term protection of fish stocks. The need for action is made even more urgent by climate change, as small pelagic fish such as mackerel and herring are particularly sensitive to changes in their surrounding environment."

we read in the note.

Atlantic: Mackerel, herring, and blue whiting at risk
Over the past decade, more than 7,2 million tonnes of mackerel, Atlanto-Scandinavian herring and blue whiting have been caught in excess of the limits recommended by scientists (Photo: Envato)

Mackerel, herring, and blue whiting: the threat of overfishing is structural

In the last decade, the MSC highlights, 100,000 fish have been caught over 7,2 million tonnes of excess mackerel, Atlanto-Scandinavian herring and blue whiting compared to the limits recommended by scientists. Fish that should have remained in the sea.

The combination of warming seas and persistently high catch levels should be a wake-up call for policymakers. We're talking about wealthy countries with abundant scientific data. They must overcome their long-standing political differences, agree on science-based catch levels, and finally agree on binding allocations for all three fish stocks.

said Erin Priddle, Regional Director for Northern Europe at the Marine Stewardship Council.

Although the most recent data indicate a slight improvement in the mackerel stock, the situation remains close to a critical threshold. If overfishing continues, "This positive evolution could be undermined, preventing the recovery of the fish population”. As for herring, the total catch is aligning with the limits recommended by ICES, while the blue whiting stock is currently in good condition in terms of biomass, “but the risk of persistent overfishing remains real".

Here are three insights that might interest you:

Overfishing, in the Atlantic there is a risk of the collapse of entire fish stocks
“Check your fish!”: sustainable fishing seen by consumers
Fish stock protection policies are not working

Northern European countries must reach an agreement on fishing quotas
Although the latest data indicate a slight improvement in fish stocks, the situation remains critical. According to the MSC, a binding agreement is absolutely essential. (Photo: Hans Hillewaert / CC BY-SA 3.0)

Location

SHARE The article

COMMENTS

Leave a comment

Alemanni News

Alemanni Logo - Sub

Related Articles

Latest from our company blog

Choosing a speargun: Itio Alemanni's advice

Interview with Itio Alemanni: the fundamental characteristics for the perfect speargun and the aspects not to...

Advanced Scuba Training: What to Know

Advanced Scuba Diving Courses: The Different Certifications (also for Freediving), Course Program and...

How to choose cold water diving gear

Protecting Yourself from the Cold with the Right Scuba Gear: What Are the Risks of Diving in...

Scuba Equipment Maintenance: The Essential Guide

Andrea Alemanni's advice for the care of scuba gear: basic maintenance and...

The secrets of freediving techniques for spearfishing

How to improve your freediving endurance: dive preparation, relaxation techniques and tips

The fascination of underwater environments: the exploration of ecosystems

Diving to discover the beauty of marine environments: exploring the underwater ecosystem of the Mediterranean and the...

Underwater fishing in summer: destinations and advice

Enjoy the summer with spearfishing: ideal destinations, lightweight equipment and summer diving tips...

History and evolution of spearguns: from past to present

Retrospective on the history of the German Arbaleti and their evolution over the years: a...